Shouldn't anyone who wants to (or is at least willing to) dedicate themselves to anything full time get exemptions and subsidies? Why is studying the Torah something exceptional in comparison to a mathematician or biologist's studies? Or for that matter, how is it any different than someone who wants to dedicate their life to playing video games all day? Shouldn't his dedication also justify an exemption and subsidies to support his lifestyle and extraordinary dedication and commitment? All sorts of responsibilities and obligations prove to be huge distractions to the hardcore gamer's drive and focus.
@PollingPlaceAbigailUnity2mos2MO
This analysis is not logical. It’s theological and about political power and money.
I agree with your basic premise. Wanting to study Talmud all day should not constitute a ground for exemption from military service. It might be a ground to request an accommodation while in military service.
