In April 2016, Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe issued an executive order which restored voting rights to more than 200,000 convicted felons living in the state. The order overturned the state’s practice of felony disenfranchisement, which excludes people from voting who have been convicted of a criminal defense. The 14th amendment of the United States prohibits citizens from voting who have participated in a “rebellion, or other crime” but allows states to determine which crimes qualify for voter disenfranchisement. In the U.S. approximately 5.8 million people are inelig…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
@9G78NC52yrs2Y
No this is protected by the fifth amendment as the right to life, liberty, and property without due process
@9G67QY82yrs2Y
No, this is protected by the fifth amendment as the right to life, liberty, and property without due process
@99NWWFC3yrs3Y
Anyone who pays taxes should have the right to vote.
@9F23VQB2yrs2Y
Yes; Except for criminals convicted of a felony, violent, sexual, or financial crime.
@984M99LRepublican3yrs3Y
Yes, but depending on what they were convicted for
@B4KK7NSProgressive6mos6MO
NO, and this also includes RUNNING FOR PUBLIC OFFICE. We should NEVER EVER be run by a president who is a convicted felon and RAPIST. It is UNCONSCIONABLE that the SCOTUS allowed this,
@9YHNZ3V 11mos11MO
it depends on the crime and sentence. the prison system should be a rehabilitation to help citizens become more productive and corrected
@9XHFG4X11mos11MO
Yes, and it should be compulsory. Voting increases civic engagement and personal investment in our systems and institutions, which can be in particularly short supply among convicts and only worsened on the inside.
@9W6GZLQRepublican12mos12MO
Yes, but only if they are tested by the government for issues and for their wellbeing. If their "fail" the test, they are prohibited to vote until the following election is going to take place.
@9W4M3FC12mos12MO
Convicted Criminals should not be allowed to vote if they are actively serving sentences and should never be allowed to vote if they are felons convicted of murder or violent crimes
@9W3VXPBRepublican12mos12MO
I think it depends the circumstance, if someone has not served their sentence, been a felon, or a murder they should not be aloud.
@9VRVX3S12mos12MO
yes except for felonies of convicted murder or violent crimes and yes after completing their scentences
@9VJQ97XIndependent1yr1Y
depending on what crime committed such as i dont think somebody put in jail for certain types of fraud shouldnt be allowed to vote but a person with a SA or other violent/sexual crimes shouldnt be
@9VJ5FZ41yr1Y
Rapists, pedophiles and murderers should not be allowed to vote. Anyone with a lesser charge such as possession of drugs or firearms should be allowed to submit an application for consideration to vote.
@9V5B9TP1yr1Y
Yes, they should. Only after completing their sentences and parole/probation. Except for felons convicted of violent crimes.
@9TZWG3N1yr1Y
Yes, depending on the crime, any assassination attempt or anything treasonist should strip your right to vote, same with murders or other seriously horrible crimes
@9TV8MFY1yr1Y
Yes, except for felons of violent crimes or murder AFTER completing their sentences and parole/probation
@9TP5KJP1yr1Y
yes but only if it was for something stupid like not paying a fine. If you steal, murder, or hurt others, or threaten to hurt others than no criminals shouldn't vote.
@9TFD4VW1yr1Y
I believe whatever you did to end up in jail and not just on a light sentence but you are a felon the right to vote should be stripped from you because its a privilege to have.
@9SMHCXT1yr1Y
If you are convicted and found guilty of violent crimes such as murder, sexual assault, and or assault with intent to harm or kill with or without a weapon, you should have your basic rights as a citizen revoked such as the right to vote. If you serve 10 or more years in federal prison your right to vote should be relinquished after parole/probation sentence has been fulfilled.
Yes but only for non-repeat offenders, after completing sentences and parole- after they have completed their sentences/parole/probation
@9SBWHPH1yr1Y
I believe that criminals should not vote because if they did they could commit voter fraud and go back to jail
@9S88DPW1yr1Y
If someone comes out of prison and becomes a law abiding citizen and isn’t arrested after a certain amount of years then yes maybe they do EARN their right to vote back.
@9RNLC4WIndependent1yr1Y
Voting is one of those inalienable human rights.
We are learning more and more how corrupt and controlling our justice system is, and the monied powers that control it continue to do what’s best to preserve their own way of life, not the majority of Americans. Further, even the majority of people involved in this system that want to do the right thing are often under-funded or incentivized to maintain the status quo. Everyone gets a voice, period.
@9RN6C7Y 1yr1Y
I think that if the person was convicted of a non violent crime and has served their sentence completely without major issues then they should be allowed to vote
@9RN2W891yr1Y
I believe that felons convicted of non-violent felonies should have their right to vote restored upon completion of their parole/probation.
@9R8RXS4 1yr1Y
Yes, but felons convicted of especially heinous crimes such as a serial killer or serial rapist should not be allowed to vote
@9QX2RP81yr1Y
Yes for convicted felons of murder or violent crime but also cover felon for fraud and things like identity theft.
@9LV28PM1yr1Y
No, but if they can't vote they should be note included in the population counts for purposes of determining representatives in Congress.
@9LTDSQ51yr1Y
Yes. However they should only be able to vote after a certain amount of time because of their sentence.
@9LMQRHP1yr1Y
Yes but to a certain point, if ones are in jail for a not so bad charge then yes. But if there are people who are crazy and kill other people then no.
@9LM3C9K1yr1Y
Felons who have committed violent crimes shouldn't be able to vote but those who did less violent crimes after completing their sentence should be able to vote along with parole/probation
@9LHYNRK1yr1Y
Yes, we need all votes as possible so it will be a even race, yet we need to make sure that the convicted criminals are surrounded by guards so they don't hurt anyone else
@9LH7MFR1yr1Y
Even if criminals were convicted of murder and does bad crimes there are still crimes that are extreme to some people. I do not think criminals convicted of a crime that they really did should not be able to vote, but if someone went to jail beacuse they had no choice or was wrongfully convicted they should be able to vote.
@9L7N2XG2yrs2Y
No this is protected by the fifth amendment concept of the right to life, liberty, and property without due process.
I feel as though it depends on their crime and the person. Maybe they would have to take a test to see if they could vote
@9L3X38T2yrs2Y
No and this is protected by the concept of the fifth amendment of the Bill of Rights where it says right to life, liberty, and property without due process
@9KV2H8R2yrs2Y
Yes, if it was for a petty or nonviolent crime that didn't cause any harm to anyone, but if it was violent, then no
@9KN5BJ3Libertarian2yrs2Y
Yes, depending on the severity of the crime if the crime is too extreme or a threat to public safety than no.
@9KDVNHP2yrs2Y
Certain people who did certain crimes should not be allowed to vote but for lighter crimes they should have
@9JYK4HJRepublican2yrs2Y
Yes if they served their time, except for felons convicted of murder, rape, or other violent crimes. Only for petty crimes.
@9JNN42R2yrs2Y
Yes, except for felons of significant crimes such as murder or arson. Including all violent crimes is to general and can exclude individuals who are systematically targeted by the justice system.
@9JJKYFD2yrs2Y
After serving their sentence and after they complete a mental exam. They must be mentally competent.
@9JH6NZB2yrs2Y
Yes, however if they have done something horrible, /or have not payed their debts, or whatever they owe.
@9JDZQCT2yrs2Y
Only if we fully know they will ant and shall not commit any more wrong doings, and if they do, they will be stripped of voting rights (depending on how serious the crime is).
@9JCXJDK2yrs2Y
Yes, but only after completing their sentences. Convicted person on parole/probation should be allowed to vote regardless. The only people that should receive voter disenfranchisement are those that have committed crimes of murder or any other crime that prevents another person from exercising their right to vote.
@9HYBTHW2yrs2Y
Depends on what the criminal actually believes in. If the convicted criminal is a genuinely horrible person, then definitely take away their right to vote.
@9HR2KRNLibertarian2yrs2Y
No for all violent crime felonies, yes for all others after sentence/Patije/probation/rehabilitation complete
@9HQN5N72yrs2Y
I think yes to a degree because when you look at people who are convicted/incarcerated they are people of color and I think and i think they should be giving the right to vote for those they think can best representative
@9HMG7N52yrs2Y
Depending on how bad their crime is and if they are guilty or not. If they give a powerful statement, haven't done a seriously bad crime (like murder), and are deeply sorry for what they have done THEN they should be able to vote.
@9H7DDB62yrs2Y
if the crime doesn't relate to taxes they should be able to because everyone who has to pay taxes should
@9H45N5G2yrs2Y
Yes for misdemeanors. No for felonies, with the option to restore their right (depending on the nature of the crime) after completion on sentencing, parole, and proof of good behavior.
@9H3NRQB2yrs2Y
Yes, after completing there time, and no if they are a sex offender and they are a felon/violent offender.
@9GTV8N22yrs2Y
Yes, but no felons convicted of murder or violent crimes, and for those who didn't do severe things, after completion of their sentences and parole/probation.
@9GQ7XD62yrs2Y
If they were wrongly accused then after getting out, they should have the right to vote. As far as people who convicted a felony, depending on the felony depends on weather they should have the right to vote or not!
@9GPFH242yrs2Y
It should be considered on a case-by-case basis. If someone has committed a nonviolent crime has served their time and shows that they have changed for the better and no longer commit crimes, then they should vote. I believe a murderer should never be allowed to vote.
They should have to go through a judicial process where a judge/official analyses if they are fit to vote.
@9GMJG67Progressive2yrs2Y
yes, once they have been proven to not have any criminal tendencies or if it was a smaller crime such as stealing or dealing drugs.
@9GCW5XRRepublican2yrs2Y
Depends on the crime if it’s not a big crime and they have been been through programs to help them then yes
@9FXC4Y82yrs2Y
This depends on what they have done wrong and if they are in the right mental state to know what they are doing by voting.
@9FVHBPHPeace and Freedom 2yrs2Y
I suppose it would depend on wether or not they would be in there for the rest of their life because if they are not coming out then what would be the point if they wouldn't be out in the country.
@9FQ5N7H2yrs2Y
Yes, but only for people involved in non-violent crimes and after their sentence
@9FHBJJJ2yrs2Y
i feel like is depends on what their crime was
@9FF58H42yrs2Y
Yes, as it is technically a constitutional right.
@9FCKM4B2yrs2Y
No as stated by the right to life, liberty, and property without due process in the fifth amendment, government has the right to not allow criminals the right to vote
@9FCFQ4K2yrs2Y
Yes, and they should be able to vote from prison while they're serving their sentences.
@9DPCDGF2yrs2Y
If a felon is sentenced to life in prison then they should not get the chance to vote but if they get released after completing their sentence and live in the community then they should get the chance to vote like everyone else
@9DL2T6H2yrs2Y
This is a poorly formed and misleading question by not differentiating between those convicted of misdemeanor crimes as compared to those convicted of a felony
@9D5X27W2yrs2Y
Yes depending on crime committed, behavior in prison/jail, number of previous crimes committed. You shouldn't be allowed to vote if you obviously fail at making educated decisions.
@8VWTQKN4yrs4Y
The right to own a gun is as important if not more than the right to vote. anyone who cannot own a gun should not be permitted to vote.
@8WN9QMK4yrs4Y
Only if they are a LEGAL citizen
@8WBP3YH4yrs4Y
@9BYWCKH2yrs2Y
Yes to a certain extent depending on if it was self defense.
@9BY4N9X2yrs2Y
Yes but certain criminals who have committed certain crimes should not be allowed to vote
@9BXFZK42yrs2Y
Yes except for felons convicted of murder or violent crimes, but only after completing their sentences and parole/probation.
@9BXCQ7S2yrs2Y
Only if the crime was not major.
@9BWYHJYLibertarian2yrs2Y
If their crime was not violent, then after they have served their time and are off of parole/probation and given mental health checks to make sure they are rehabilitated.
@9BTFZ972yrs2Y
Depends on how long after they were released
@9BP3HNF2yrs2Y
Yes, but their vote should only count as half a vote
@9BNG3LC2yrs2Y
Yes, depending on the crimes committed
@9BMS8PVRepublican2yrs2Y
Depends on how long they were sentenced for and what they were convicted of or they should have to take some form of testing to be eligible.
@9BJNLM22yrs2Y
Yes, but they need to pass a test to make sure they are sane
@9B2VSDL3yrs3Y
It depends how severe was their crime and how old were they
@99ZMR9B3yrs3Y
Yes but only because taking away the right to vote from criminals incentivizes people to wrongly convict others to strip them of their right to vote
@99VCYZ83yrs3Y
Yes, but only those convicted of minor, non-violent crimes and have completed their sentence and parole requirements.
@98FB9HQIndependent3yrs3Y
yes accept child predators and ect
@9724S2M3yrs3Y
I believe it should depend on the crime committed.
@96W9VT23yrs3Y
Yes, but not if they are in prison or jail.
@96VBDB93yrs3Y
I dont think people should vote in general
@96Q25M23yrs3Y
Only if there found innocent
@96NQR563yrs3Y
Yes, but there should be a mental check
@96NF4SZ3yrs3Y
Yes, but not for those who’ve committed the most horrific crimes
@96M7N3B3yrs3Y
Should get a 5 year timeout, if they are clean in those 5 years after leaving prison, then they get the right to vote back.
@96LFXRD3yrs3Y
Yes, if they pass a psych evaluation.
@96JTTSG3yrs3Y
Yes, except for felons convicted of murder or violent crimes unless they can prove themselves innocent or changed in some way.
@96JR26M3yrs3Y
It depends on what they did and how serious it was
@96JH7ZL3yrs3Y
Yes, except for citizens convicted of murder
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.