In some progressive universities, professors provide “trigger warnings” to students before discussing sensitive topics, emotionally charged issues, or events that may trigger post-traumatic stress. “Safe spaces” are places where students can gather to avoid a speaker or event that offends them.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
@9VZHHFPRepublican 12mos12MO
No, if we decide to censure our education then we might stop teaching about important events in our history such as the holocaust, 9/11, and slavery, also we shouldn't have designated safe spaces for students because our education shouldn't be divided based on personal information, people should just be treated the same regardless and not create divides and preferential treatment in the students
@HelcovichEmireRepublican6mos6MO
Absolutely! Learning about hard topics is important.
@B2LRVB8 8mos8MO
yes, but not nessacerily mandatory, thoughts in college should be challenged and encourage an open mind
@B5GY7XP5mos5MO
No, however universities should be mindful of how different students may react and feel about subjects and situations and offer support to those who may be worse prepared to handle those situations
Yes, Some special need students need a quiet space to calm down in while getting their degree. They are trying to be productive members of society and support themselves they should have a space to calm down and relax when they get overwhelmed.
@9WZFY3C11mos11MO
they should add them, as every place should be somewhere safe for students in post secondary education.
@9VDP2BD1yr1Y
Yes, they should. I'd be rather annoyed and irritated if a classmate of mine got trigged by course material, and trigger warnings could make an easily-trigged student not show up.
@9V4J3PL1yr1Y
I think the students should have the responsibility to inform professors if they need a safe space or trigger warnings
@9T4NJ721yr1Y
No, but students and student organizations should have the right to use trigger warnings if they choose and to create safe-spaces on campus
@9SXKNDL1yr1Y
This can be optional for private universities but not acceptable acceptable for publicly funded universities.
@9SGKYK5Progressive1yr1Y
Training should be provided in how to set up brave spaces and ways for students to participate and professors and students to be accountable. Safe is not guaranteed. Content warnings yes. Also support to students like being able to sit near a door, access needs. Also this somatic training starts younger, not just in university.
@9PW926Z1yr1Y
I do think that it is important to warn students of disturbing or triggering conversations but these students should be prepared to handle sensitive subjects and be able to decide for themselves what the boundaries of their mind are.
@9NBKD6Q1yr1Y
Yes, it's important for students to feel comfortable but if its something relevant to the real world like the holocaust and history like that students should at least get watered-down information. Sometimes you need to have difficult conversations
@9KZ6F6Z2yrs2Y
It should be up to the instructor or presenter for trigger warnings, and the university for safe spaces. Not the business of the government.
@9JWTG3B2yrs2Y
Yes, provide trigger warnings but limit safe spaces to individuals who suffer mental health episodes because universities should be a place to foster learning and different perspectives
This should be voluntary for universities. Reducing the harm of undisclosed trauma should and must come from a universal mental healthcare system.
Universities should strive to create an inclusive space for all students, without segmenting them into outgroups, to encourage interaction with new ideas.
@9HPZ8Q62yrs2Y
Trigger warnings for things like excessive violence, rape, etc., should be commonplace, but putting a trigger warning on anything that could even potentially be offensive is not only harming individual growth, but also very distracting for everyone. If an individual genuinely needs trigger warnings for things that most people consider perfectly fine, they need help.
@9D8YKMB2yrs2Y
Each school can make their own decisions.
@9BWL7TT2yrs2Y
Up to the university not the government
@9BVLS352yrs2Y
No, campuses already have counselors on site for “safe spaces” go back to your car, dorm, library or somewhere else to be alone for a bit. If anything increase the quality and quantity of mental health professionals on campus
@9B2BDDSLibertarian3yrs3Y
this is hilarious and no
@974QDPX3yrs3Y
No, but make it clear if the university offers them or not.
@9727S2L3yrs3Y
Universities are free to do as they choose.
@96H8P993yrs3Y
Yes, but it doesn't need to be overdone
@968DJX63yrs3Y
I think having safe spaces and trigger warnings can be more inclusive, and allow for people with different support needs to have better access to education, similar to IEPs. But I don't think it should be mandatory.
@93ZL7V63yrs3Y
Yes, I would, but it's the college's choice to do this or not. This is not a political issue.
@93CNM4R3yrs3Y
If they want to, they can.
@8ZKXSKG4yrs4Y
Colleges naturally give more weight to challenging students' thoughts and opinions while trigger warnings likely may have the unintended consequence of increasing avoidance behaviors in those with PTSD making it more difficult to overcome said PTSD whilst negating intellectual challenges on controversial topics pertaining to race, sex, capitalism, imperialism, and religion for studies. The same may occur in safe spaces, which may procure the development of echo chambers and stifle necessary intellectual debates with those of opposing philosophical views, negating resiliency in the proces… Read more
@8ZB34QB4yrs4Y
no, shut up and cry in the bathroom like everyone else
@8YHFVTN4yrs4Y
No, studies have shown trigger warnings have the opposite effect from intended anyway.
@8YG4YP34yrs4Y
Let the university decide on that, but if people really need them I am okay with making universities provide them.
@8X3LJRQ4yrs4Y
To a degree trigger or content warnings should be used (for flashing, gore, the typical stuff) as well as students should have an available safe space
@8W2XS3L4yrs4Y
No, unless you're showing gore or something. Then I guess trigger warnings are warranted.
That's up to the college.
@8TZ39474yrs4Y
This should not be regulated by government; universities should be allowed to choose this for themselves.
It’s the college and the student’s decision.
Yes, provide “safe spaces” and “tigger warnings”. Some people suffer terrible anxiety and don’t need more negativity in their life.
@8S44V2D5yrs5Y
No, thats what a bathroom is for. Building a "safe place" would just be wasting the college's money.
@8RS3S4B5yrs5Y
No, if you need a safe space grow up and look at the world for what it is. Stop being scared of everything and weak. Find your own safe space.
@8RL7ZN2Libertarian5yrs5Y
Yes, college is meant to challenge students and we do need to know real life but people also sometimes need safe spaces and trigger warnings
@8RHTM4P5yrs5Y
i think safe spaces would be nice but some people just get too overboard with trigger warnings like they need it for the smallest light or a slightly harmful joke its really annoying i get with like trauma or self harm but some people just need to shut up.
@8RHG5B65yrs5Y
If students need these in college how are they going to survive in the real world where these are rare.
@Rezzvoir5yrs5Y
What we really need is to make classes that get people mentally ready for the world around them, that way they don't end up getting hurt or hurting others, whether it's physical or mental.
@8PQ4LSS5yrs5Y
I think trigger warnings should be provided for those with PTSD. Safe spaces, however are bogus.
@8PC2R9WRepublican5yrs5Y
No, They shouldn't need them
@8NZM97K5yrs5Y
Yes, but students should be informed and prepared for the harshness of reality, in which there will be no trigger warnings. However, there should be "safe spaces" for people any and all individuals that need sanctuary, regardless of the circumstances, so long as they themselves don't prove to be a danger to others in said space.
@8NXHNZT5yrs5Y
No, it’s a waste of tax money
@8LTXNCV5yrs5Y
No, but they should be allowed
@8J4BWK65yrs5Y
Yes, provide trigger warnings, and direct students to seek counseling during those sessions so students truly affected will get help, and others will not just skip out
@8HS5R6L5yrs5Y
I don’t understand the question
@8GHRLR35yrs5Y
Yes, if they want to, but they shouldn't be forced to provide them.
@8FG5BTWRepublican5yrs5Y
College is a place to explore all views some may be offensive but if not allowed to explore these issues students don’t learn how them maybe ineffective or flawed
@8F27CQ85yrs5Y
Individual professors can do what they think is necessary for their own community of learners, but should work toward building resilience, courage, and openness to new ideas.
@8DVRL3N5yrs5Y
Colleges should be private and able to make their own decisions on this
@8DLQS855yrs5Y
I think they should be offered and given but students should be encouraged to get out of their comfort zone and learn how to handle situations instead of hide from them.
@8CYDV3F5yrs5Y
There should be adequate mental health support for those who need it, but schools should not need to tip-toe around certain subjects just to make students comfortable.
@8CDVW5Q5yrs5Y
Yes if the student body votes in agreement to have the spaces available.
@8C5LM5Z5yrs5Y
Yes, but ensure that it is not abused in order to get out of class
@9D3HJF22yrs2Y
No, students need to be afforded the opportunity to challenge the views espoused by prejudiced, misogynistic, racist, xenophobic, homophobic and religious speakers.
I believe this issue has gotten so misrepresented I do not feel a "yes" or "no" answer does justice
@9B6DCZ83yrs3Y
yes, they must require safe spaces and require trigger warnings if a professor is teaching about something that is a sensitive topic.
@99S6W6X3yrs3Y
No, because anything can be a trigger and if you were to cater to everybody every piece of media would have a warning of some sort.
I agree that trigger warnings can be important for people with legitimate PTSD and shouldn't be used to shelter people from opposing viewpoints, although I can't think of any situations where a trigger warning keeps people from hearing other ideologies, I mostly see it used for things like wounds or graphic images that people would just rather not see. I think the safe space idea is a little trickier because it really depends on what you would define as a safe space, as I think it varies heavily from person-to-person and situation-to-situation.
I think that depending on the topic a heads up would be nice, but in general no. life doesnt come with "trigger warnings" and safe spaces i mean yeah that should be provided.
@98JKW6Y3yrs3Y
they should but its up to the college
@98FH45M3yrs3Y
I think it’s a kind thing to do, but hard to require. So it would depend on how it’s put in place
@98BCQS23yrs3Y
It’s the school’s choice how they run their university. If you don’t like it, find another school.
@97YMKFMRepublican3yrs3Y
no and neither should high schools, high school and college are meant to prepare you for the real world not coddle us and try to protect our feelings
@97Y6T9P3yrs3Y
Abolish government schools.
@97Y3RQC3yrs3Y
No, but if a student requests it to a professor it should be provided
@97G4N6Z3yrs3Y
Trigger warnings should only be provided with excessively graphic content
@97D3RCX3yrs3Y
Only if it's for something graphic and genuinely triggering such as murder or suicide, not small things that only one person needs, they should get help for that instead of making it everyone's responsibility
@97BHC483yrs3Y
It should be allowed but not required.
@96Z62J43yrs3Y
This should be completely up the university, however I have questions on how this could be run.
@942SKSVLibertarian3yrs3Y
No, and all schools should be defunded and privatized
@8WDYTMSRepublican4yrs4Y
both would be helpful to some, but it might cause a distraction for other people.
@8TG5Z3S4yrs4Y
they should add trigger warnings for stuff that's really going to be an issue in the "real world" ex. TW: flashing lights, needles, blades, blood but yes and also safe spaces
@8QBRNB75yrs5Y
yes this would make many more students feel comfortable and safe with going to school.
@8Q2C8NB5yrs5Y
No, this just leads to censorship and discrimination
@8L9G2M75yrs5Y
No, but private universities may choose to do so if they wish.
@8GHR3HMRepublican5yrs5Y
No, make classes to teach students how to handle thoughts and opinions that challenge their opinions.
@8G4Q43J5yrs5Y
It should not be required, but having them present would be helpful
@8G2XSSF5yrs5Y
Provide content warnings, not necessarily trigger warnings or safe spaces. It's entirely dependent on the topic at hand.
@8RKDFWP5yrs5Y
If students can't handle what others say and do when they are not harming or violating the rights of others, what are they going to do when they school?
Universities should decide if they want to do this or not
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.