Try the political quiz
+

25 Replies

 @BBPT7FWPeace and Freedom from Pennsylvania  disagreed…4mos4MO

If you are born a male, then you play male sports; if you are born a female, you play female sports. Whichever your birth certificate says should be the gender you play .

 @BBPR6P8 from Iowa  disagreed…4mos4MO

The best counter argument would be that no if you are trans in any way you do not get to play in the "new gender" you say you are sport. if you are biologicly female you play in female sports, If you are biologicly a male you play in male sports, story ended.

 @BBRBCMF from Alabama  disagreed…4mos4MO

Male to female transgenders should absolutely not be able to participate in women sports- why is it ok for a man to claim they are a woman and it is not ok for a white person to decide to be black- it is ridiculous.

 @BBQFKNN from Missouri  disagreed…4mos4MO

Many females can get hurt if the hormone levels aren't regulated, and allowing male to female transgender into locker rooms, should also be banned because it can cause many female athletes to feel uncomfortable. Male to female transgender people are stronger than normal women and putting them against one another can hurt the actual female. There should be a separate transgender sports so that either way nobody gets hurt.

 @BBQ2YY9  from Pennsylvania  disagreed…4mos4MO

Athletic performance is influenced by biological factors where women will never be as strong as men, therefore if you are born a male you should only be alowed to perform in mens sports, and if you are born a female you should only be allowed to perform in womens sports.

 @BBPYTHHRepublican from California  disagreed…4mos4MO

You can't change what you where born with so once you are a boy you are a boy. Same goes as if a girl. Men are also scientifcly proven to be better than women on a physcial stand point.

 @BBPWPPC from Alabama  disagreed…4mos4MO

Male to female transgenders should absolutely not be able to participate in women sports- why is it ok for a man to claim they are a woman and it is not ok for a white person to decide to be black- it is ridiculous.

 @BBPN4SQ from Texas  disagreed…4mos4MO

Add a new category when the numbers are sufficient. In the meantime, use birth gender to determine category

 @BBPDJWT from New York  disagreed…4mos4MO

Whatever gender you are assigned at birth is the sex of sports you can participate in. If a girl will benefit more from being on a boys team then that's fine, but a male who is statistically stronger, should not be allowed in women's sports.

 @BBPD84HRepublican from Missouri  disagreed…4mos4MO

it makes it unfair for people in sports like a boy competes in girls sports it's in fair to the girls.

 @BBPCDVW from Utah  disagreed…4mos4MO

or they could just accept that they are not what they "think" they are and participate in their right gender group. if you are not good enough to perform with your born gender that you should not be performing, not everyone can be and Olympian, that's the point. they should quit taking the easy route.

 @BBPBPS8 from Iowa  disagreed…4mos4MO

Ban transgender athletes no matter what. It is unfair and obtuse to think that a person of a one gender can say they are the opposite gender and compete against that opposite gender.

 @BBP8W8S from Missouri  disagreed…4mos4MO

I believe that it does not matter whether you are transitioning from one gender to another, you should play under the gender you are given at birth. As an athlete through my educational career, I would find it uncomfortable playing against the opposite gender especially in contact sports such as basketball. I understand there are some exceptions such as football where this is padding and if a lady wants to take the risk and play football, go for it. But, I personally would not find myself comfortable guarding the opposite sex in a basketball game.

 @BBP458G from Texas  disagreed…4mos4MO

It is unfair simply due to science in any circumstance. Men are born stronger than women and it will always be that way.

 @BBPR4PXRepublican from California  disagreed…4mos4MO

They shouldn’t have a choice to be in the opposite gender race. They should compete in the biological gender because that is what they were born todo.

 @BBNZ7PF from Pennsylvania  disagreed…4mos4MO

If a man is a man he should not be able to play in womens sports. That is completely unfair because men are biologically stronger than women. This also affects Title IX because if a man can play in a sport, it becomes a male sport, unbalancing the sports for both genders requirement.

 @BBP2L82Independent from Ohio  disagreed…4mos4MO

If FTM transgender athletes choose to play a sport for the sex that they are not assigned to, that’s their fault if they want a disadvantage. But, MTF athletes should be banned from competing against Females because it is not fair whatsoever.

 @BBNZVQW from Pennsylvania  disagreed…4mos4MO

Males are built a lot stronger than women just genectically so it would not be fair for a woman to go up against a biological man. And also you dont hear about girls breaking mens records or making a big wave in the standings. You hear men alot more making controversial endings, wether its at the Olympics or other huge events where woman have worked their whole life for just to loose to someone who cant excel at their own biological genders sport and has to become a girl.

 @BBNZTS7Republican from Texas  disagreed…4mos4MO

Same genders should only play each other in sports nothing more. The hormones signify significant advantages in men compared to women.

 @BBNZ7PF from Pennsylvania  disagreed…4mos4MO

Males are stronger than females. It is completely unfair to have a man play in a womens sport. It completely violates Title IX and is one of the dumbest things that democrats and feminists support.

 @BBNHD6X from Ohio  disagreed…4mos4MO

While hormone levels can be somewhat regulated, they don't negate all biological advantages. A trans gender women may still retain advantages due to body structure/ body mass and development in puberty. Which can make a significant difference.

 @BBNC9GN from Texas  disagreed…4mos4MO

Male to females have a way bigger advantage and will put the real females at a higher risk of injury. If female to male is at a disadvantage how is male to female equal.

 @BBN9VKGLibertarian from Pennsylvania  disagreed…4mos4MO

Hormone levels do not change the fact that bone density, strength, and more will always favor the male.

 @BBNC454from Guam  disagreed…4mos4MO

no they shouldnt be allowed to compete at all, as they use enhancment of any form or even evoloutanary enhancment

 @BBTXNQT from South Carolina  disagreed…4mos4MO

What your born as should who you compete against in sports you should not get special treatment and have an advantage against other because you decided to change for the worse.

Engagement

The historical activity of users engaging with this disagreement.

Loading data...

Loading chart... 

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...

About this author

Learn more about the author that submitted this disagreement.

Last activeActivity1 discussionsInfluence1 engagementsEngagement bias100%Audience bias100%Active inPartyLibertarianLocationUnknown