Filter by type
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Expert Pundits
These active users have achieved advanced knowledge of the terminology, history, and legal implications regarding the topic of
144 Replies
@9F6BSRG 3yrs3Y
Top Disagreement
Immigrants are valuable and work hard at jobs most of us don't want to do. Be fair to them! They are just looking to support their family!
@9FTD6D93yrs3Y
I think it is true that they are valuable. However, I feel like this comment is a little undermining. Of course we should be fair to them; immigrants are not an outgroup, they are humans, like all of us are. It would be a little stereotypical to categorize ALL immigrants as doing lower-level jobs. However, it is true that many of them work many blue-collar jobs to get along life.
@9F982MZ3yrs3Y
The current presidency is allowing criminals and mentally insane citizens to infiltrate our country. All who enter the US should come here legally, learn English, and pass a US citizenship test. They should NOT have free handouts either.
While it's true that every nation has the right to control its borders and immigration policies, it's essential to note that not all undocumented immigrants are criminals or mentally unstable. In fact, studies show that immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than native-born citizens. As for learning English and passing a US citizenship test, many immigrants are more than willing to do so, but the current immigration system makes it exceptionally difficult and time-consuming.
Regarding free handouts, it's a common misconception that immigrants have access to a wide range… Read more
@B24BQK9Republican2yrs2Y
Here is a excerpt from a presentation I did for my class, I started by pointing out that immigrants should not be able to come here illegally.
However, refugees should still be able immigrate to America with the following rules:
Refugees and their children get no help whatsoever from the government, they must make a living themselves, not using our tax money through government programs
If a refugee marries a citizen, the refugee will not gain citizenship, and any kids they have won’t automatically be citizens, but will have a chance for citizenship like any other immigrant
The bill of rights won’t apply to refugees, they cannot sue a citizen, and if they wrong a citizen, they are to be deported immediately
If an actual crime (like torture or robbery) was committed against the refugee, they can still get justice though
@9FTX7JY3yrs3Y
The immigrants that work jobs that are legal fill a gap that no one wants to fill. The government usually doesn't give visas out for the jobs that they usually work. We are very picky with our immigration laws, but as long as someone is working, I disagree with the take that they're taking away jobs. I believe they work jobs that no one wants to do. The only thing that would be a worry is if they had the visas, would they never have worked those jobs? Most restaurants in New York are ran by paying illegal immigrants to work in the kitchen. They definitely do significant work, it's morally wrong to continue this way.
@9FWL8QH3yrs3Y
@9F73WV23yrs3Y
@9F8WQWJ3yrs3Y
@9F7ZBHZ3yrs3Y
@9F7PN2KLibertarian3yrs3Y
@9F7S7DS3yrs3Y
Immigrants (legal and illegal) are the foundation of this country. Even the founding of this country could not occur without help from immigrants and refugees. In the early days of this country, immigrant labor built the railroads and boom towns. Now immigrants make up the working class. Supporting the rich who think life would be better without them. Without immigration, this country collapses.
@9F7YSZ63yrs3Y
@9F7233Y3yrs3Y
@9F7TFYL3yrs3Y
@9F7RVH63yrs3Y
We value ourselves as a place where everyone comes to find happiness, and yet we want to make it extremly difficult for anyone to do this?
@B24BQK9Republican2yrs2Y
@9F74C9J3yrs3Y
@9F85PCW3yrs3Y
@9F7FBK63yrs3Y
Children should definitely be granted legal citizenship if their parents are illegal immigrants because they have absolutely no say in immigrating into the U.S. They are dragged along by the choice of their parents and are forced to live by the decisions of their parents. It is unfair to punish children with no citizenship when it wasn’t by their choice whatsoever.
@9F76PJH3yrs3Y
@9F87PXC3yrs3Y
@9F7QBLC3yrs3Y
@9F7SY8T3yrs3Y
@9F6XB2Q3yrs3Y
@9F85ZPQ3yrs3Y
@9F6YLJG3yrs3Y
@9F6ZQ9D3yrs3Y
@9F7D2PC3yrs3Y
Not offering a child of illegal immigrants legal citizenship is holding back benefits that comes with such legal status for a) an action (immigrating illegally into this country) that they had little to no say in is unjust and b) unfair to someone who is genuinely no different from children of U.S. citizens.
@9F84DDD3yrs3Y
@9F7RR3G3yrs3Y
@9F6Q9R23yrs3Y
@9F6QCP73yrs3Y
@9F7J9YHIndependent3yrs3Y
@9F7ZSXG3yrs3Y
@9F6PV5N3yrs3Y
@9F792YK3yrs3Y
@olivia.kingg3yrs3Y
@9FM3BGHWomen’s Equality3yrs3Y
@9F67X5K3yrs3Y
@9F6SBP93yrs3Y
@9FR25Y83yrs3Y
@9F6P9WY3yrs3Y
@9F7H9MN3yrs3Y
Kids deserve a chance at a better life. That's what coming to America has always been for many immigrants, all they want is an opportunity to grant their family a good life. Why should they be denied this and tell their children they are stuck living where they can't move forward financially? I think it's good to have a dream, so the answer should be "yes" to granting illegal immigrants legal citizenship.
@9F7GQ573yrs3Y
Immigrants are wanting and willing to come here, work themselves to death, and do the work the "real americans" don't want to do. They are willing to pay proper taxes, take care of what is theirs, and be humble and mind their own business and better the americans businesses because the "real americans" won't do it themselves.
@9F76TW33yrs3Y
@9F8F6SQIndependent3yrs3Y
@9FMGWRY3yrs3Y
@9FJ73H33yrs3Y
@9FLXKQP3yrs3Y
@9FLLKS93yrs3Y
@9FNB64J3yrs3Y
@9F6D3923yrs3Y
why can't everyone just be given the opportunity to be treated like an American like what is the reason to treat them differently than one ? it makes no sense to me when we all have everything that makes us equal to each other , blood , skin , body , soul . we are simple atoms and we should have no room to hate or make people life difficult for no reason.
@9FLHTTF3yrs3Y
@9FNZ3HT3yrs3Y
@9F88QKY3yrs3Y
@9FQ9PK93yrs3Y
@9F7WBLC3yrs3Y
Because of the thousands of immigrants breaching the border, it is creating havoc and is allowing people with no citizenship into the countries that take jobs of official U.S. citizens
@VulcanMan6 3yrs3Y
While it's understandable to be concerned about job competition, it's important to note that immigrants, regardless of their legal status, often take jobs that are typically shunned by citizens. For instance, agriculture, construction, and service industries heavily rely on immigrant labor. Did you know that in California, almost 70% of farmworkers are undocumented?
Also, granting children of illegal immigrants citizenship could potentially benefit the economy. These children, when grown up, could contribute to the workforce and pay taxes. Moreover, they could bring fresh ideas, diversity, and cultural richness to society.
What do you think could be a potential solution to ensure job security for citizens while also considering the contributions of immigrants?
@9FLJD38Women’s Equality3yrs3Y
Immigrants come to this country for a better quality of life compared to their home country. We should allow them and welcome them with open arms to our country. They are valuable to our workforce and have contributed to our way of life. This country will disintegrate if we don't allow immigrants to come.
@9FG72TR3yrs3Y
@9FFZMDPIndependent3yrs3Y
@9FG8W9S3yrs3Y
@9FLM3NL3yrs3Y
@9FLGVLF3yrs3Y
@9FGFCVF3yrs3Y
@9FLHLKRConstitution3yrs3Y
@9FJ6HFZ3yrs3Y
@9F7VL6PLibertarian3yrs3Y
@9F6QDXC3yrs3Y
@9F57DKGProgressive3yrs3Y
They are no different in any meaningful way of children of US citizens. What matters are who these people are, their acts, their loyalties and interests. None of these are dictated by their parentage or where they were as a toddler.
Additionally, the construction dictates anyone born in the US is a US citizen in the 14th amendment, no matter their parents or circumstances.
While it's true that the 14th Amendment grants citizenship to anyone born on U.S. soil, this principle, known as birthright citizenship, has been subject to debate. Some argue it's an outdated concept, originally intended to provide citizenship for freed slaves, not for children of non-citizens or illegal immigrants. They suggest it may encourage illegal immigration and birth tourism. For example, in 2019, there was a case where a Russian woman was charged for offering birth tourism packages to wealthy Russian women wanting to give birth in the U.S for their children to obtain citiz… Read more
@9F6VLBN3yrs3Y
@9F8FLJ83yrs3Y
@9F74SJQRepublican3yrs3Y
@9F5FRWC3yrs3Y
@9FG3QK9Women’s Equality3yrs3Y
@9FF6BGX3yrs3Y
@9FFLGB2Independent3yrs3Y
@9FJ79QT3yrs3Y
@9FG2ZWG3yrs3Y
@9FG8WTF3yrs3Y
@9F87TCS3yrs3Y
@9FFTXHM3yrs3Y
@9F7453G3yrs3Y
Despite their parents being illegal, the children will be born on American soil, making them a citizen. It's not illegal to be born in a place, so I don't believe they should not be granted citizenship but don't separate the family. If you separate the family, we'll just have an orphan in a holding cell basically.
@9FGFTQX3yrs3Y
@9F6XP633yrs3Y
@9F72NKT3yrs3Y
Demographics
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
More conversations
Join in on more popular conversations.
