Try the political quiz
+

Engaged Voters

These active users have achieved a basic understanding of terms and definitions related to the topic of

103 Replies

 @9FG2GZ6 disagreed…3yrs3Y

Top Disagreement

No U.S. citizen should have to go thorugh atleast one year of military service because many kids when they reach their teen years, know what they wanna do with their life and may not need that year of training for something that'll set them back in life.

 @9FG476MDemocrat from Texas  agreed…3yrs3Y

I agree that military service should never be mandatory. It should be a choice to join as it's not an environment that is fit for everyone. Not all people are fit for that kind of rigidity and intensity.

 @9FFYFK2Democrat from North Carolina  disagreed…3yrs3Y

Some people wouldn't be able to, or wouldn't want to, go out for months at a time away from their family and potentially endanger their lives.

 @9FGS3G9Independent from Illinois  disagreed…3yrs3Y

18-year-olds should focus on college after school unless they really desire to do military service it serves no purpose to force people who are 18 to have at least 2 years of military service.

 @9F7V4HZ from California  disagreed…3yrs3Y

Some people are not psychologically or physically prepared for the military, and people who are doing good for society and making a living should not be stripped from that

 @93L698J  from GU  agreed…1yr1Y

An extended time in service to the military will enable full training and deployment, while keeping additional servicemen and women on standby in case of conflict.

 @9GDLXG4  from Utah  agreed…3yrs3Y

Citizenship should be considered a privilege, not a fundamental right. The privilege should be earned through service. This is true for all people, immigrants and native born. The country needs a unifying force, and young individuals need a sense of purpose. For many, Mandatory Service provides both. However, I believe in public service alternatives for those who recoil at the military's necessarily violent programs.

 @B8CQ85G  from Mississippi  disagreed…8mos8MO

It disregards individual rights and individual morality. Mandating Military Service would likely increase resentment towards the government and weaken patriotism. Removing millions of people from the workforce and education could also severely weaken the economy.

 @B4GB6W8 from Texas  agreed…1yr1Y

As a combat veteran and ESL teacher having lived and worked in 20 countries, I have seen first hand the benefits of participation in military service.

 @B3PRXB2 from Pennsylvania  agreed…1yr1Y

We need a strong defense force an an adequate military age population that is ready for a potential war and to defend our nation state and war efforts.

 @B2LX7RDRepublicanfrom Washington  agreed…1yr1Y

If you don't want to serve your country, you may as well be a traitor and unpatriotic to the nation.

 @9MKVSV7Independent from Minnesota  agreed…2yrs2Y

Two years is a good balance between not enough time and too much time. They will still live a long life after without being burned out, while still reaping the benefits (mentally) of military service.

 @9M9ZRFSAmerican Solidarity from Alaska  agreed…2yrs2Y

A single year is not enough for mandatory service since training can take anywhere between four months to two years depending on the job. Thus, mandatory service should be at least four years so that the conscripted can actually serve rather than just do basic training, tech school, and then leave within a few months. It simply just does not make any sense for mandatory service to just be a year.

 @9RDDSGCCommunist  from Florida  agreed…2yrs2Y

My hypothesis is that conscription has the following benefits:

1. Obviously, dramatically decreased military-spending by requiring fewer career military members; conscripts only typically receive necessary equipment, their quarters, food, and a small stipend, whereas contract soldiers receive all of the same necessities but also must be paid enough, both in terms of direct salary and post-service benefits, to justify signing up.

2. Having a populous in which most adults have served, have firearms training, and so on, means even post-service, the nation becomes far more difficult, if not impossi…  Read more

 @9LZGQ7G from Arizona  agreed…2yrs2Y

It is your patriotic duty as an American citizen to support and defend these United States of America that have nurtured and protected you throughout your life. If you've never wanted to join the military at some point in your life, you are nothing less than a traitor to your own country.

 @9LWMSXHDemocrat  from Texas  agreed…2yrs2Y

We already know that the vast majority of kids are NOT ready for college and all the rest either can’t afford to go or are not interested in going. We also know that the human brain doesn’t fully mature until early twenties and a short two years of military training will vastly improve that. Once they are out they will not only be more mature but will qualify for the college fund. I believe if we did this many more people would graduate college and it’s a flat fact that a better educated public is a better country. Finally if we had this in place and we go to war or something similar our people would far more ready. That readiness shows the world how much stronger we are as a nation. Look at Israel, they do this and as small as they are they don’t take **** from anyone. I am absolutely convinced this program would work.

 @9GFRDHS from Texas  agreed…3yrs3Y

kids nowadays need discipline, look at most tiktok 18 - 30 year olds recording themselves doing stupid **** , we need to preemptively correct them

 @9F8QM48 from Illinois  disagreed…3yrs3Y

I believe that there should be more than 2 years of service as not everyone will fully understand the laws and regulations after only 2 years.

Engagement

The historical activity of users engaging with this answer.

Loading data...

Loading chart... 

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...