Yes, but not until they are teenagers
Filter by type
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Filter by author
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Expert Pundits
These active users have achieved advanced knowledge of the terminology, history, and legal implications regarding the topic of
Informed Voters
These active users have achieved an understanding of common concepts and the history regarding the topic of
Engaged Voters
These active users have achieved a basic understanding of terms and definitions related to the topic of
289 Replies
@9FP4T83Republican 3yrs3Y
@B8QV76X 7mos7MO
Top Agreement
Teaching about systemic racism and historical inequality is important, but waiting until students are teenagers makes sense because older students have the cognitive maturity to understand complex social issues. Research proves that structured, age-appropriate lessons on racism can reduce bias and improve empathy, but introducing these topics too early risks confusion, superficial understanding, or emotional overwhelm. Teenagers are also better positioned to engage critically with history, civics, and current events, allowing them to see connections between past injustices and present dispari… Read more
@B8RZ8DZ7mos7MO
@B8R4N6JRepublican7mos7MO
@B8R3Z8VRepublican7mos7MO
@9GJSXT4Independent3yrs3Y
@B84Z458 8mos8MO
No one at any age should be taught Critical Race Theory, period. It is a racist ideology and should never be taught.
@B89JSL98mos8MO
@B89CFD88mos8MO
@B89C4LP8mos8MO
@9GJMHK4 3yrs3Y
If schools cannot teach religion or gun safety, schools should definitely not tell students false news about how the United States has always been racist, because it hasn't.
@9GJQ2573yrs3Y
@9FMYNYD3yrs3Y
@B9XBDYB 5mos5MO
Around age 11 or 12, children enter the Formal Operational Stage. This is the first time the human brain is biologically capable of abstract reasoning and "thinking about thinking."
@B9Y4QDP5mos5MO
Just because they are initially biologically capable of understanding does not mean that they are protected from harmful ideals. There are basic bipartisan things that need to be taught, math, science, english, but they need to be taught without a lens to be sure that the child is able to form their own opinion when they are older.
@B9XZSBJ5mos5MO
@B9XYY8P 5mos5MO
Critical race theory is racist in itself and has no modern backing showing that white men/women have any government or fundamental advantage over anyone else, teaching this to children 12 and under who are more likely to absorb information with no self ideals to reflect off of is inherently wrong and immoral
@9FPL4FZProgressive3yrs3Y
@9GYWPMZIndependent3yrs3Y
Teenagers are growing to being adults and can understand a topic way better then someone who might not understand the concept of racism.
@9GZ6SVR3yrs3Y
@9GKWN873yrs3Y
No, we should not teach teenagers Critical Race Theory (CRT) either, we should not attempt to "teach" anybody let alone children, that there is an underlying division between them just because of their race. It is believed that teenagers in High School will NOT mature anymore after graduating or dropping out, this means
@9GKXK5J3yrs3Y
@9GKX4TVRepublican3yrs3Y
@9GKXFGP3yrs3Y
@9GXYCR83yrs3Y
@9GSGFHM3yrs3Y
@9FMSJX83yrs3Y
@9FPSLNK3yrs3Y
@9FPSRN63yrs3Y
@9FMQYWX3yrs3Y
@9FNGYJFIndependent3yrs3Y
@BDPQ3DX1mo1MO
@9GL9DR63yrs3Y
@B7X8SNQ8mos8MO
@9GZNRT53yrs3Y
During middle school and high school thats when our differences really show. In lower grades you don't notice much but once we become more independent than thats what leads us to seeing differences such as different allowances and incomes and clothing. Bullying is already a problem in schooling systems but mostly with higher grades because smaller kids have there teachers to monitor it and have a smaller understanding of the things around them .
@9FQ3N3X3yrs3Y
@B8DS4338mos8MO
@9FPZFNFRepublican3yrs3Y
@9FTJKSLWomen’s Equality3yrs3Y
@9FMRHBH3yrs3Y
@9FL2L3X3yrs3Y
@9H42JGV3yrs3Y
@9FSMXWJ3yrs3Y
@9FR7KCJ3yrs3Y
@9FM2XKY3yrs3Y
@9FPW9VW3yrs3Y
people in our society talk a lot about race already, and having the subject further drilled into young could end up having the opposite effect, like it sometimes has on different issues. the fact is that if everyone would simply stop talking about and making such a big deal about race then racism basically wouldn't exist.
@9FPXBN63yrs3Y
@BBHHN2PIndependent 4mos4MO
@9FPWDTB3yrs3Y
@9FQYMRY3yrs3Y
This is better, but I'd like to counter the whole argument by making it mandatory for students who are involved in PROVED racial disputes. We wouldn't want the youth to be wrongly framed and forced to go through a course they don't have to, and we wouldn't want to teach them about racial differences because what happens if that plan backfires?
@9FNCVZ9Republican3yrs3Y
@9GCG2RP3yrs3Y
@B7MD9PTRepublican9mos9MO
@BBP58P54mos4MO
@B9VLC5Y5mos5MO
@B994N6Q6mos6MO
@B7KRVXTRepublican9mos9MO
@B7BTNHF9mos9MO
@9HPWYY53yrs3Y
@9HHPT5B3yrs3Y
@9HBVPSS3yrs3Y
@BF2D6DW2wks2W
@BDJJV391mo1MO
While critical race theory has significant purchase as a legal theory, it has blind spots like any framework. An honest accounting of history is much more important to me than CRT. There are valuable criticisms of critical theory that need to be discussed as well. I am not for the suppression of knowledge and embrace open inquiry. It’s important to introduce young adults to a range of perspectives and let them debate. The question is also a bit misleading as critical race theory is not being taught in high school. It should continue being taught in college though I have no qualms about young adults being exposed to a wide variety of frameworks across the political spectrum. Debate is beautiful.
@B9VCS3R5mos5MO
Older students have the cognitive maturity to understand complex social issues. Research proves that structured, age-appropriate lessons on racism can reduce bias and improve empathy, but introducing these topics too early risks confusion, superficial understanding, or emotional overwhelm. Around middle school and high school is when those differences are really noticed. In lower grades you don't see much but once you're older, you've learned and experience with the world, and your cognitive functions are more developed that's what leads us to seeing and understanding those differences.
@B9SB6XB5mos5MO
@B9JT8X85mos5MO
@B9B5Y376mos6MO
@B8XDJF4Independent7mos7MO
@9HPWSJZIndependence3yrs3Y
@9HPSV7MRepublican3yrs3Y
@9HPNS28Constitution3yrs3Y
@9H998HY3yrs3Y
It does not matter at what age you decide to convince children that our country is inherently racist. It still only aids to the perceived problem that our country is racist. If our country was truly inherently racist, minorities would not be able to achieve the level of success that many have.
While this is an oversimplification, it makes the point.
@9FNCJBT3yrs3Y
@B8BR7FG8mos8MO
@B866TLD8mos8MO
@B7NYH97Constitution9mos9MO
@9HH5MQT3yrs3Y
There is no reason for it to be taught. Not only is it a theory, meaning it is not a real science, it has no real use for students. The subject itself explains racism from a single, extreme perspective. It is better to teach real, blatant history. If students are educated well without bias, they will then form their own opinions.
@BB4YZZ4Libertarian4mos4MO
@B9TM79WLibertarian5mos5MO
@B9MHCVTRepublican5mos5MO
Essentially, this actually teaches racism. It teaches that if you are black or another race of color, you are failing only because of your race and oppression from white people, that colored people need sympathy and support to succeed, and that if you are white, you are a racist and part of the problem.
@9HGVLJYRepublican3yrs3Y
@9FLWJ953yrs3Y
@9G6JMXP3yrs3Y
@9GSVDJQ3yrs3Y
@9GDHZCS 3yrs3Y
@9G4P434 3yrs3Y
@9H267RXRepublican3yrs3Y
@9GT9HVZRepublican3yrs3Y
Teenagers go through a lot, and pushing CRT on them as well would make them even more unstable, and it's just not a good idea.
@VulcanMan6 3yrs3Y
@9FM33SW3yrs3Y
@9FLYG4F 3yrs3Y
@9G5DHSS3yrs3Y
@9G46RTKIndependent3yrs3Y
@9G3T6PS3yrs3Y
Engagement
The historical activity of users engaging with this answer.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Demographics
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
More conversations
Join in on more popular conversations.





